Section 518

Where we endeavor to stay positive about the 2011 Mets…

Thank You, Philly!

Posted by JD on April 26, 2010

The Phillies signed first baseman Ryan Howard to a five-year, $125 million extension (with a team option for a sixth year, which, if exercised, would make the total value $138 million). Thank you, Ruben Amaro!

There are two reasons for my reaction: the impact on the Phillies’ payroll, and the ripple effect throughout the league. Let’s tackle them in that order.

The Phillies’ Payroll: According to Cot’s Baseball Contract’s, the Phillies payroll for this season is about $138 million. That’s bound to increase next season as they already have commitments to 17 players exceeding $134 million. They can basically kiss Jayson Werth goodbye, and they better hope their farm system produces a few cheap replacements, because they’re not going to be able to spend a lot on the open market.

Now, you can’t blame that on entirely on the extension because 2011 is the final year of Howard’s current deal: the Phillies were already committed to (over)paying him. The extension starts in 2012 and the Phillies payroll for that season is already $86 million (for just eight players). Now, this is where it starts to get fun. Howard will be 32 that year and, mostly likely, he’s going to be an old 32. Adrian Gonzalez and Prince Fielder will both be free agents heading into that season (barring any trades or extensions, obviously) and will be 30 and 28, respectively. The Phillies commitment to Howard, who can’t play anything but first (and not very well at that), takes them out of the market for Gonzalez and Fielder. As much as we all love Ike Davis, the Mets would have to get involved. With the Yankees committed to Mark Teixiera and the Phillies out of the game, they’d probably have only the Red Sox as competition, meaning Davis would be moving out to the outfield in 2012.

The Ripple Effect: This is what makes me positively giddy. Howard is inferior to both Gonzalez and Fielder, yet the Phillies just signed him to an extension that has an average annual value greater than everyone other than A-Rod. Think their agents aren’t sending gift baskets to Citizen’s Bank Park? What’s particularly intriguing about the scenario is that Milwaukee and San Diego are two of the smaller markets in the league. They don’t have the resources to devote $25 million to one player. The Mets do, and they’re aided by an additional factor: Carlos Beltran’s $17 million contract comes off the books after 2011, giving them even more payroll room*. It’s like the Perfect Storm: the Phillies took themselves off the market, but elevated the price tags to the point that only the large market teams can afford to pay them.

*As much as I love Beltran, I’m slowly coming to grips with the fact that he may never be the awesome force that he once was. He’ll turn 35 in 2012 and will likely still be dealing with the fallout from his current injury. I just don’t know how wise it would be to resign him to a big-money deal. Only time will tell, but for purposes of this discussion I’m going to assume that the Mets will look to move on.

And then there’s the elephant in the room: if a 32 year-old Ryan Howard is worth $25 million a year, what is a 32 year-old Albert Pujols worth? $35 million? $40 million? More? The Cardinals have substantially more flexibility in 2012 than the Phillies with only $31 million committed to just four players (but my gosh, how horrible does that $12 Kyle Lohse commitment look now?). But I have to think that if Pujols refused to give the Cardinals a discount, they’ll be hard pressed to meet his demands.

If Pujols does hit the market, the Mets will face competition from both the Yankees and Red Sox (regardless of who they have under contract at the time). Landing Pujols would be a long-shot, but stranger things have happened. And we would have one of our most hated rivals to thank for making it all possible.


3 Responses to “Thank You, Philly!”


    Ryan Howard’s first four full offensive seasons place him second to Pujols in the league currently. It’s definitely worth $25M/year.

    Yes, the Phils are overpaying for future performance, and he’s going to be OLD when it’s over. But what this does is raise the bar for everyone, including the Pujolses and the Gonzalezes, and if Scott Boras isn’t foaming at the mouth in expectation of getting Fielder the $30M/year that HE really isn’t worth.

    Sure your points that only the Mets and other higher payroll teams would be able to get the elite players are correct. However, what’s bad is the precedent it sets. If Howard is worth 5/125, is David Wright worth 4/90 in his next contract? Is Pelfrey worth 3/45? If Reyes bounces back from injuries this year could he get the same?

    What about the teams that can less-afford for these increases? The deceptively productive Jorge Cantu in Florida is up at the end of his current $6M contract. What would it cost Florida to lock him up for 4 years (1 arb year remaining, I think) … would it be $12 million for that year? And another 3/60? Florida can’t afford that. And don’t get me started about Pittsburgh.

    I think that even if this is good for the big market teams, we will have more of a disparity with the lesser 2/3 of the league.

  2. JD said

    Howard is a good player, but not the second best player in the league. Heck, he’s not even the best position player on his own TEAM (Chase Utley is). That’s not to say he isn’t worth a lot of money, but not that much. Not by a long shot.

    As to your other points, the Wright and Pelfrey numbers you threw out there aren’t much of stretch, if you add a year to them. Remember, Ollie got 3/36 two years ago. If Pelfrey stays consistent, 4/45 would be a steal. I don’t have a handy comp for Wright, but 5/90 doesn’t sound too far off to me (a little high, but not by much).

    And if it increases the disparity with the majority of the remaining teams, well, I don’t really care. While I feel bad for fans of those teams, their success doesn’t matter as much as putting the Mets in the best possible position to win. Sorry if that sounds cruel.

  3. Oh I understand where you’re going, I’m just saying that by overpaying Howard it sets bad precedent. Will the Mets want to have a $200M payroll when all these contracts come up in the next couple of years? I think not — Pujols or no Pujols.

    Also, and you don’t mention it here but it bears mentioning, contracts are for offense. Ryan Howard could play first base like the Liberty Bell and he’d still be getting really close to that amount, although possibly on an American League team. Utley’s a good player, definitely. But he’s a threat to have a .280/50/150 season any time soon.

    I agree that you’re thinking from the perspective of the Mets and I can appreciate that. But we’re getting to a point where the Mets and the Phils will be like the Yanks and the Sawx — each winning 95 games while the rest of the division is under .500.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: